A husband walks away after 20 years of marriage in Strangers - A Memoir of Marriage, by Belle Burden. One person still loves and the other does not, and the former conveys the story of one divorce along with observations of an osprey couple, lifelong mates, nesting on St Martha’s Vineyard and probing questions for her readers. One person is still in love, and the other doesn’t, not knowing why.
For Burden, the marriage ends in the midst of the COVID quarantine with little warning. She receives an anonymous call from a man reporting that his wife is having an affair with her husband. In retrospect, she finds some red flags. “And doesn’t it all look different, wouldn’t your own story look different, if you knew how it was going to end?”
Friends and acquaintances offer two categories of response, those who looked her straight in the eye, forthright about Belle’s plight, and others with vague responses, distancing themselves and refusing to engage. And she bristles with friends who spot differences: "You were much harder to know,” suggests one friend, adding she was tense, stressed. “You had walls up.” Still, the conversation sheds light on why the marriage’s failed and Burden admits she could compile a list of features her husband may have disliked. “And couldn’t you make your own list? Isn’t there always a list?”
The friend goes on to describe Burden as lighter, more relaxed. “I know you loved him, and you loved your marriage, your family. But you are yourself again, more like the Belle I knew in 1985.” And Belle realizes she is liking and enjoying herself for the first time in a long time.
Marriage had made her less authentic. But the end brings pain as every location, every holiday, in her community produces a rush of memories, every holiday. Burden describes the pain of Christmas cards:
“Day after day, they arrived, nearly a hundred images of happy, intact families. It was also the year many couples I knew, my contemporaries, celebrated their twenty-fifth anniversaries, the milestone I would never reach…. Each card … felt like a dagger. I knew they had nothing to do with me…. Still, the pain of it was staggering, like the postman was delivering daily bombs, reminders of what I had lost, I was no longer one of them. I was something different now. … I wanted to scream, I thought I had that too! I loved and was loved in the same way! There is nothing different about us!
“When each card arrived, I tore it in half, ripping through children and babies, husbands and wives, through smiling faces, and dropped it in the trash.”
Burden didn’t send Christmas cards in 2020 and claims she never would again.
Eventually, she returns to practicing pro bono law with a friend, filing asylum cases for immigrant children who fled poverty, abuse, gang violence and more. “It forced me to think about something other than my divorce. It also forced me to acknowledge how myopic, how grandiose, I’d been about my own story… it was seeing the scope of life, the challenge, of suffering, of what human beings endure….”
The final months before the divorce is finalized is spent sorting out finances with lawyers and a judge. Decades earlier, her family had urged a prenuptial agreement, but she acquiesced to revisions suggested by her husband. She also used her trust funds to purchase properties in both their names. Such decisions later haunted her. During twenty years of marriage, her husband, even while quietly earning millions, controlled the family finances and even accepted tuition money for three children from Burden's stepmother. Over the years, Burden had convinced herself “that he was taking care of me,” she explains. “And I could see that the cost for feeling safe was being controlled.”
She cannot imagine trusting again, let alone falling in love. “It wasn’t just trusting that they would be faithful, it was trusting that I could believe in what they presented to me, that they weren’t harboring an alternate self, one I couldn’t see.”
Her husband often suggested the decision to divorce was mutual, and many friends do not recognize her pain. So Burden sets out to write the story to sort her thoughts and find her voice in relaying difficult truths. She submits an essay to the Modern Love column of the New York Times and after a long wait, an editor expresses interest, but suggests changes including a line that mentioning the family continues to work on custody arrangements. Burden is blunt, explaining that while her ex-husband continued to join the family at key events like graduation, he made it clear he did not want custody other than dinners on Thursday nights. At the editor’s request, she runs the essay by her husband and he approves.
The response is overwhelming, and once again Burden divides people into two groups - those who express gratitude and admiration for her honesty and others who blast her for going public with a personal issue.
Burden understood full well her children would ponder every word – and she eloquently explains that was part of her goal. “I hope because I was open about what happened to me, my children will insist on intimacy, on knowing their partners deeply, on being known deeply. I hope they will talk to their partners about money, about what will happen if the partnership ends…. I hope that as they build trust in their relationships, they never lose sight of their own authority, their own voice, their own intuition. I hope they will move toward people who are in pain, rather than away….”
One reviewer called the book a “must read for every wife – and husband.” The book is also a wakeup call for any of us with friends going through divorce, an essential guide for knowing what to say and helping them through a complex, lonely and difficult time

