Saturday, October 31

Living a lie

 











A fine line can exist between developing a good attitude and pretending happiness or religious devotion to outright lying.  

In the remarkable and thought-provoking debut novel by Caro Claire Burke, Yesteryear, Natalie Heller grows up with a mother who regularly lies about the basic foundations of their family. The daughter attends Harvard, but goes through life both settling for dreams, manipulating how others might view her, overcoming social awkwardness, battling to become likable. She leaves college to marry the spoiled son of a wealthy US Senator, and encourages the father to buy the couple a large ranch in Idaho. She promises the man a large family that no average woman could easily handle, and become a social media influencer about organic farming, a simple lifestyle, the growing family and their faith. Natalie likes to think that she hears the voice of God, and becomes famous for “tradwife” messaging – attracting both devout women striving for an idyllic family life and angry liberals who view the quest as impossible, with all the makings of a cult. 

The family's image a charade as Natalie hires help, lots of help, and Yesteryear ranch is entirely performance, her children illiterate and ignorant about the world at large who become as they age virtual props and slaves around the home and ranch. “Those homesteading folks over at Yesteryear Ranch, with the tired young mother and the grinning doltish cowboy? They were, as it turned out, not rotten at all, but a perfectly fermented vision of America.” 

Natalie releases a stream of curated images and videos, with no public interviews or spontaneous clips, and dedicates time to disciplined messaging and not letting others know her true self. “The goal of an influencer is not to be lovable, and it is not to be unbearable. The goal is to be both at once. In other words: addicting.” 

Her upbringing provided perfect training. Natalie’s mother was positive but not quite trustworthy, and Natalie reflects on the woman's life lessons, including assurances around childbirth, as a “long, golden string of insincerity that threads together the entire human race: a shared agreement between women to insist back and forth in endless conversations that this thing we spend our whole lives preparing for – this thing we were here for – is anywhere close to what we thought it would be.” Similar patterns unfold in Natalie’s life. “You never age out of it. Your mother lies to you, an then you lie to your children, and then your children lie to their children, and then you an old woman, looking back at your own life, lying to yourself. “

Everyone lies, Natalie concludes, and her online world falls apart as her angry interior monologues, including critical observations and labels for others, are voiced aloud. 

A staff member goes public with the true story of Natalie’s family, just as the father-in-law launches a presidential campaign. Transformed from social media darling to pariah, Natalie endures destitution, isolation and mental breakdown – waking up one day in what seems to be a filthy and bare frontier cabin from 1855 with a strange new husband and another set of children. 


Saturday, October 10

Many forms of love

 

Love Forms by Claire Adam begins with a 16-year-old in Trinidad impulsively having sex and becoming pregnant by a partner she does not know. 

As the pregnancy becomes obvious, her parents act quickly - sending Dawn away until the child is born and can be put up for adoption. Her parents take rapid-fire control, without considering the emotional consequences, and making arrangements to smuggle her to a convent in Venezuela where she waits out the pregnancy, immediately giving up the baby girl after birth. 

Communication is strained, and her parents pretend the pregnancy never happened. Dawn relocates to Great Britain to study medicine, yet the memories and pain linger throughout her medical career, marriage, raising two sons, divorce, and regular visits to Trinidad. A sense of loss develops with age, and Dawn regrets that she and her mother never spoke about the daughter “properly.” Her mother advised keeping the unwanted pregnancy a secret from her husband, but he later reads her medical chart when she gives birth to their son. . 

As her son grows, she imagines her daughter as a student, comfortable and productive. “It was that happy vision that made it possible for me to live, most of the time, like an ordinary person. But then, of course, there were other times when the realization of her absence returned. It always arrived somewhere in my abdomen, the sudden shock….” 

The husband's career takes priority over Dawn's and eventually the two divorce. Decades later, she begins searching for the daughter, pleading for details from her family, writing letters and taking DNA tests. But the convent, the town, and the family who adopted the baby are unknowns. She no longer cares about the secret and realizes how little she understands herself, imagining how family members and neighbors in Trinidad might have gossiped about her.  

Dawn's parents are impatient with her curiosity, refusing to discuss the matter, and Dawn impulsively tries the opposite approach with her own sons, telling them about their half sister when they are young, ages 7 and 5. Yet all she can share is the mystery of what she doesn’t know. She cannot answer their questions, instead replying that she would “explain it better one day, when they could understand.” 

Longing to know the child's whereabouts becomes a lifelong obsession. Dawn had only a few moments with the child, holding her to her chest, after a sympathetic nurse breaks the rules. Despite such limited time and details, the bond of love remained strong.